The Working Paper Trap: Confessions of an Unrepentant Uploader

If academic and policy writing had a Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, I would probably be diagnosed with acute Graphomania Praecox—the compulsive urge to formalize every geopolitical tremor, energy shock, or philosophical puzzle into a 20-page working paper and upload it directly to ResearchGate before the ink of history has even dried.

Case in point: last spring, my co-author (an attentive AI interlocutor) and I published From Tension to Conflagration: The Middle East War and the Early Emergence of the Age of Tension. The ink was barely set on the PDF before shifts in maritime friction, maritime choke points, and multipolar realpolitik demanded an Annex C.

Looking across my drive on this quiet holiday, it is worth asking a candid question: What is structurally wrong with my publication strategy?

As it turns out, quite a lot. If you treat research as an iterative, living project rather than a static monument, you inevitably run into three classic flaws of the prolific self-publisher:

1. The Velocity Trap: Faster Than Peer Review, Slower Than a Tweet

Traditional academic peer review is famously glacial: submit today, get reviewer comments in nine months, see print in 2028 when the war you analyzed is already in the history textbooks.

The alternative—publishing open-access working drafts and rapid updates on ResearchGate—gives you agility. But it creates an awkward velocity paradox. You are analyzing deep, long-wave structural transformations (The Age of Tension, institutional trust architectures, civilizational narratives), yet you are constantly tempted to update them like a rolling newsroom blog. When the world shifts every week, when do you close the document and say: “This stands as a snapshot of its time”?

2. The Granularity Gap: Where Macro Meets the Strait

When you think in broad historical arcs—like our earlier Layered Futures: Thinking Through 2100—the temptation is to explain everything through grand structural dynamics: institutional decay, multipolarity, demographic tides.

The flaw in rapid follow-ups is that reality has a nasty habit of being stubbornly micro. A sweeping thesis about civilizational friction suddenly hinges on whether a specific container line will pay the war-risk insurance premium to transit the Bab-el-Mandeb, or whether a handful of precision interceptors in a naval battery are running low. Big-picture thinkers often risk floating too high above the plumbing, or diving so deep into the week’s tactical updates that they lose the horizon.

3. The “Unbundled Monograph” Syndrome

Prolific writers don’t actually write 50 disconnected papers. They write one gigantic book in 50 disconnected installments.

  • On Monday, it’s an essay on democratic accountability architectures.
  • On Wednesday, an analysis of oil price cycles and geopolitical shocks.
  • On Friday, an update on maritime choke points and multipolar diplomacy.

The flaw isn’t the substance; it’s the distribution architecture. Readers encounter individual fragments floating on ResearchGate or LinkedIn, while the underlying, cohesive architecture—how energy volatility, institutional trust, and asymmetric warfare reinforce one another—remains trapped inside the author’s head (and their hard drive).

The Verdict: Flaw or Feature?

Could one streamline this? Absolutely. I could pause, withhold publication for three years, smooth over every evolving edge, and produce a polished, leather-bound volume that is immaculately peer-reviewed, pristinely formatted, and obsolete on arrival.

Or, one can treat writing in the Age of Tension as an open-source, iterative process: laying down hypotheses, testing them against breaking reality, openly adding Annexes when the world defies the model, and engaging with the argument in public.

It’s messy. It violates traditional academic etiquette. But in an era where the international order itself is being rewritten in real-time, perhaps an evolving working draft is the only honest way to think out loud.

Politics and science: 1924 and 2024

Note: This is just a copy of my LinkedIn post of today. I thought it would be interesting to share it here, too.

A few years ago, my amateur publications on ResearchGate led to an invitation to an online conference on low-energy nuclear reactions (LENR). LENR research was formerly known as cold fusion research but this term is out of fashion because the experiments have not (yet) led to getting more energy out than what is being put in (and, yes, some scandals around fake research too). I still regularly receive newsletters from the organizer: the Société Française de la Science Nucléaire dans la Matière Condensée (SFSNMC). I understand little of the nitty-gritty of these experiments but I find them fascinating. Let me come to the point I want to make here.

I just received the proceedings of the 16th international workshop, which was co-organized just two weeks ago with the International Society for Condensed Matter Nuclear Science (ISCMNS). Because of the political situation, Russian scientists could, apparently, not participate this time. In the newsletter I got, the organizers deplore that. For example, an eminent cold fusion expert like Anatoly Klimov was not there this year. However, he did share a rather wonderful letter to his European colleagues which I also got as part of the proceedings and which, as far as I can see (again, I do not understand all that much of it), is full of practical recommendations to move forward in this field. Indeed, Anatoly Klimov is not just anyone: he was one of the more prominent presenters at the much more high-profile ICCF-23 conference, which was held in Fujian, China. [Talking about China: China’s large (hot) fusion project seems to be moving (much) faster than ITER….]

The point is this: the exclusion of Russian scientists in events like this is like cutting ourselves off from cheap Russian natural gas or other inputs, or like stopping to export German cars and other industrial products to Russia. We do not hurt Russia with that: we only hurt ourselves – Europe. The situation resembles that of the 1924 Solvay Conference, which was a subdued affair because of the boycott of German scientists (even Albert Einstein, despite considering himself to be Jewish, also did not participate out of solidarity with his German scientific colleagues). When and how will this international nonsense stop? Russia was part of Europe in the 19th century. Why can’t we live with Russia now?

A small piece of good news is, perhaps, this: the small Russian team at ITER apparently has not been sent back home yet (see this Polico article on that). It suggests we simply cannot move ahead without the Russian engineers and scientists: they are, quite simply, ahead of us in this field and, therefore, their knowledge and skills are apparently too valuable to get rid of. Double standards once again, apparently… :-/