The dark force

We have the electromagnetic force, the strong force, and it looks like there is a dark force too now! Mr. Michael Gottlieb, the publisher of the online edition of Feynman’s Lectures, is actively exploring it: I received yet another DMCA take-down notice for so-called unfair use of the material (see below) and, yes, this hassle has some history already, unfortunately—so it is bad news.

Now, it is true I do refer quite often to these lectures—but I do so because they are a commonly referenced textbook: one needs some kind of reference when referring to mainstream physics, isn’t it? In fact, I am amazed Mr. Gottlieb was able to claim copyright on a textbook that was published 57 years ago and whose author is long dead! I should also add that I started this blog on Feynman’s Lectures before Mr. Gottlieb’s online edition of it became online! Shame on him! However, it looks like he’s got the upper hand in this nasty game so I’ll just bow out and that will be it. I’ve got better things to do than fight some narcissist who thinks of a 1963 textbook as personal property!

The material Mr. Gottlieb objects to is in older posts mainly—but he has been scrutinizing more recent posts as well. The use of the diagram with the energy levels of electron orbitals in a lithium atom in my May, 2020 post, for example, is apparently not permitted—despite me mentioning the source of this diagram quite explicitly. In short, it looks like many of my posts on this blog will look quite mutilated soon. Worse, the host of this WordPress site (Automattic) may decide to take down my site altogether.

I know there are dark forces fighting freedom of expression and independent thought everywhere. I just hadn’t expected them to be present in science too. This is, effectively, a lot worse than just being told to ‘shut up and calculate’ or – more commonly – being referred to as a ‘crackpot’ theorist. I, therefore, actually do feel sad about it. :-/ Any case, if the site goes down, I would like to thank my readers here – especially those who are actually following each and every post – for their encouragement. It has been a good exercise, and I will continue to publish, of course, using other channels and references other than Feynman. Keep tracking independent research on, and

I wish Mr. Gottlieb the best of luck: I can only hope he learns some real physics while continuing to scrutinize my posts. Just for the record, I would like to understand this correctly: Mr. Gottlieb put Feynman’s Lectures online – verbatim – but so he is not copying stuff. And so I am trying to do some creative stuff with it – not copying literally but effectively using some of Feynman’s material to provide a new perspective or make a point – and so it is me who is the offender here, right? That’s the situation, isn’t it? Or is my logic faulty here? We really do live in weird times. Weird but interesting, at least.

I have various working titles for a future book on physics, but ‘The Sorry State of Physics’ is still my favorite one. In fact, Oliver Consa is probably right when calling it plain rotten. And, yes, at this occasion, I’d like to recall my previous advice: do not buy Feynman’s Lectures, please. They are outdated and you can, therefore, not learn all that much from them. They have, unfortunately, become what Feynman did not want them to become: Cargo Cult Science, zealously guarded by a bunch of self-appointed Mystery Wallahs. Be well and happy, and please do keep thinking things through for yourself!

Jean Louis Van Belle, 18 June 2020

Fenton (Automattic)

Jun 17, 2020, 10:17 PM UTC


We’ve received the DMCA takedown notice below regarding material published on your site, which means the complainant is asserting ownership of this material and claiming that your use of it is not permitted by them or the law. As required by the DMCA, we have disabled public access to the material.

Repeated incidents of copyright infringement will also lead to the permanent suspension of your site. We certainly don’t want that to happen, so please delete any other material you may have uploaded for which you don’t have the necessary rights and refrain from uploading additional material that you do not have permission to upload. Although we can’t provide legal advice, these resources might help you make this determination:

If you believe that this DMCA takedown notice was received in error, or if you believe your usage of this material would be considered fair use, it’s important that you submit a formal DMCA counter notice to ensure that your site remains operational. If you submit a valid counter notice, we will return the material to your site in 10 business days if the complainant does not reply with legal action.

Please refer to the following pages for more information:

Please note that republishing the material yourself, without permission from the copyright holder (even after you have submitted a counter notice) will result in the permanent suspension of your site and/or account.

Thank you.


110 thoughts on “The dark force

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s